The motte-and-bailey fallacy (named after the motte-and-bailey castle) is a form of argument and an informal fallacy where an arguer conflates two positions that share similarities, one modest and easy to defend (the "motte") and one much more controversial and harder to defend (the "bailey"). The … See more Philosopher Nicholas Shackel, who coined the term, prefers to speak of a motte-and-bailey doctrine instead of a fallacy. In 2005, Shackel described the reference to medieval castle defense like this: A Motte and Bailey … See more The fallacy has been described as an instance of equivocation, more specifically concept-swapping, which is the substitution of one concept for another without the audience realizing. In Shackel's original article, he argued that Michel Foucault See more • Argumentation scheme • Argumentation theory • Bait-and-switch • Cognitive bias • Intellectual virtue See more An example given by Shackel is the statement "morality is socially constructed". In this example, the motte is that our beliefs about right and wrong are socially constructed, while the bailey is that there is no such thing as right and wrong. According to … See more Responding to Shackel's use of the motte-and-bailey concept, professor of rhetoric Randy Allen Harris objected to what he saw as the use of the concept to gratuitously violate the principle of charity by distorting other people's arguments and failing to See more • Anadale, Christopher (10 June 2024). The Motte & Bailey Fallacy (Lecture) (video). YouTube. Retrieved 19 June 2024. See more WebTone policing. A tone argument (also called tone policing) is a type of ad hominem aimed at the tone of an argument instead of its factual or logical content. Ignoring the truth or falsity of a statement, a tone argument instead focuses on the emotion with which it is expressed. This is a logical fallacy because a person can be angry while ...
The Motte-And-Bailey Fallacy and Hadith – Quran …
WebOct 14, 2024 · The mother of all Motte and Bailey Fallacies in monetary economics. That the dollar is money, and gold is not. The Mother of All Mottes and Baileys. The broad assertion implies that the dollar is the unit of account, the measure of value, the store of value, and the extinguisher of debt. And that gold is a barbarous relic. This bailey cannot … WebA fallacy of diversion which makes a controversial claim then substitutes an easy & obvious claim for it, pretending they are identicalLogic playlist: https:... raisin gluten free
Motte-and-bailey fallacy - Wikiwand
WebAnswer (1 of 7): In some respects, there’s a family resemblance because both are fundamentally about how propositions/arguments are represented. So with the motte and bailey technique, you claim (when attacked) that you’re defending some modest proposition (the motte) but in other contexts defend... WebA motte-and-bailey castle is a European fortification with a wooden or stone keep situated on a raised area of ground called a motte, accompanied by a walled courtyard, or bailey, surrounded by a protective ditch and … WebThat aside, motte-and-bailey actually IS a great fallacy to know and expose when you see it, but from my experience it's far from the biggest issue with online discourse. The biggest issue is that people are way too dumb and lack the knowledge required to have certain conversations in the first place and simply talk past each other half of the time. haydee la orotava